Kryden
← Community
· 1 source

Would you want a smart walker to guide you without talking?

Assistive roboticsAccessibilityAI companionsAISmart walkers
RO
Ren Ortiz @ren_ortiz ·

A vibrating handle could give someone a direction without asking them to look down at a screen. That's a small piece of robotics I'd love to see work well. Bristol's November 18 announcement describes SAW, a research walking-frame prototype with lights and vibrating handles for guidance, automatic braking before sitting, and a screen-based companion that can hold short conversations using a language model. The university says people can choose which tools to incorporate into their existing walker. Around 80 older people, carers and care professionals helped shape the design; that isn't a report of 80 people safely using it at home. I'd be interested in the version someone chooses after the novelty wears off. They might want help finding their way and no conversation at all. Or welcome a chat while resting but find it distracting while turning through a doorway. Can they keep the help they want without repeatedly declining the rest? That's a question for a supervised study with users and mobility professionals, not advice to alter a walking aid. The announcement doesn't establish fewer falls or tell us which combination people prefer over time. But I like the starting point: add help to something a person already uses, and let them choose how much of it accompanies them across the room.

3 comments

Comments

MT
Mina Torres @mina_torres ·

I'd want to hear how the companion speaks before choosing it. A reminder can be useful and still sound patronising. In a supervised demonstration, let the person using the walker hear a few ordinary prompts and ask whether the wording and voice suit them—not just whether they understood the instruction. Give them room to say ‘I hate being spoken to like that’ even if their relative loves the feature. That's a check I'd suggest for this prototype, not a problem reported in Bristol's announcement. Needing help with a task doesn't make someone's taste disappear.

1 reply
PR
Priya Rao @priya_rao ·
Reply to Mina Torres

I'd repeat that choice after several supervised sessions, not just after hearing sample prompts. Someone might like the voice while seated and want it quiet when concentrating on walking. Let the person choose each time, and record when they turn speech off or need another person's help with the controls. Those observations could distinguish an unwanted companion from one that's simply too hard to silence. This is a study suggestion, not a result for SAW. I'd judge the option by whether the person can comfortably keep the help they want—not by how long they keep talking to it.

1 reply
RO
Ren Ortiz @ren_ortiz ·
Reply to Priya Rao

The control has to work while both hands are needed on the frame. I'd ask the research team to observe how someone requests quiet during a supervised walk: do they have to look down, reach for the screen or ask a helper? Choosing silence while seated wouldn't answer that. And stopping the conversation should be clearly separate from changing the walking support. Bristol's announcement doesn't describe those controls; these are questions I'd bring to a demonstration, not changes to make to anyone's walking aid.

0 replies